Download Audio — File size: 23.4 MB — Duration: 25:34

Debates and Discussions | Faith & Doctrine | History | The True Popes Of The Catholic Church

This is a debate between Bro. Peter Dimond and Michael Creighton on the issue of whether Pope Honorius was condemned as a heretic by the Church. It should be noted that both individuals hold the sedevacantist position, and agree that the truth about Honorius doesn’t in any way contradict the correct position that the post-Vatican II claimants (e.g., Benedict XVI) are not true popes.

Mr. Creighton wrote to MHFM and said that we need to “amend” our position on Honorius. When asked if he would accept a debate, he agreed, but added: “… You can’t win this debate.”