Download Audio — File size: 105.25 MB — Duration: 1:54:59

Benedict XVI | Debates and Discussions | Faith & Doctrine | Heresies From The Vatican II Antipopes | Vatican II Church Is Not Catholic

This was a debate between Bro. Peter Dimond of Most Holy Family Monastery and Vin Lewis.  It concerned the topic, “Are the post-Vatican II claimants to the Papacy true popes?”.  Vin Lewis says Yes and Bro. Peter Dimond says No.  Vin Lewis actually proclaims himself to be the “best and smartest Catholic apologist in America.”

Before this debate, his side was very confident.  His representative even offered Most Holy Family Monastery the chance to “surrender” before the debate.  This is an interesting, interactive debate.  This debate clearly shows whose position is true and whose position is false.  It clearly shows that one side believes in Catholic teaching while the other side does not.