Vatican II Debate (Dimond vs. Sungenis) on Nostra Aetate #3 and the Muslims
August 2, 2011
Copy Link
Copy Embed - English Channel

Download Audio File Size: 150 MB — Duration: 1:05:46

| | | | | |

This is a new debate between Bro. Peter Dimond and Robert Sungenis. It took place on Tuesday Aug. 2, 2011. The topic debated was the teaching of Vatican II on the Muslims in Nostra Aetate #3.

The resolution for the debate is: “Vatican II’s teaching on the Muslims in Nostra Aetate #3 is false, heretical, and contrary to the teaching of the Catholic Church.” Bro. Peter Dimond takes the affirmative: that Vatican II’s teaching is false and heretical. Robert Sungenis takes the negative: that Vatican II’s teaching is not false and heretical. The relevant portion of the passage that was debated is as follows:

“Nostra Aetate #3- The Church also regards the Moslems with esteem. They adore the one God, living and subsisting in Himself; merciful and all- powerful, the Creator of heaven and earth, who has spoken to men; they take pains to submit wholeheartedly to even His inscrutable decrees, just as Abraham, with whom the faith of Islam takes pleasure in linking itself, submitted to God. Though they do not acknowledge Jesus as God, they revere Him as a prophet… Finally, they value the moral life and worship God especially through prayer, almsgiving and fasting.”


Do You Evangelize?
8 years ago
Why Most Pro-Lifers Are Not Truly Pro-Life
14 years ago
SSPX Mini-Schism
11 years ago
The Secret Intentions Of Benedict XVI’s New Book: “The Infancy Narratives”
11 years ago
Francis Endorses “Fr.” James Martin In New Letter
2 years ago
A Man With A New Perspective About Vatican II And The Church
12 years ago
The Scourging Of Jesus Christ
12 years ago
The Best Argument Against “Baptism Of Desire”
9 years ago
The True Story behind The Exorcism of Anneliese Michel / Emily Rose
14 years ago
No Baptism, No Salvation – Pope St. Leo The Great
2 years ago
The Latin Text Of The Oldest Surviving Papal Decree Rejects “Baptism of Desire”
9 years ago
How Many Serious Sins Do Protestants Think A “True Believer” Can Commit?
1 week ago
What Francis Really Believes (4th Edition)
8 years ago
Real Demonic Possession
16 years ago
Desolate “Church,” Predestination, and “Invincible Ignorance”
14 years ago