Vatican II Debate (Dimond vs. Sungenis) on Nostra Aetate #3 and the Muslims
August 2, 2011
Copy Link
Copy Embed - English Channel

Download Audio File Size: 150 MB — Duration: 1:05:46

| | | | | |

This is a new debate between Bro. Peter Dimond and Robert Sungenis. It took place on Tuesday Aug. 2, 2011. The topic debated was the teaching of Vatican II on the Muslims in Nostra Aetate #3.

The resolution for the debate is: “Vatican II’s teaching on the Muslims in Nostra Aetate #3 is false, heretical, and contrary to the teaching of the Catholic Church.” Bro. Peter Dimond takes the affirmative: that Vatican II’s teaching is false and heretical. Robert Sungenis takes the negative: that Vatican II’s teaching is not false and heretical. The relevant portion of the passage that was debated is as follows:

“Nostra Aetate #3- The Church also regards the Moslems with esteem. They adore the one God, living and subsisting in Himself; merciful and all- powerful, the Creator of heaven and earth, who has spoken to men; they take pains to submit wholeheartedly to even His inscrutable decrees, just as Abraham, with whom the faith of Islam takes pleasure in linking itself, submitted to God. Though they do not acknowledge Jesus as God, they revere Him as a prophet… Finally, they value the moral life and worship God especially through prayer, almsgiving and fasting.”


Remnant TV And Robert Siscoe Refuted And Exposed On Sedevacantism
10 years ago
Response to a heretic on the CMRI and other false traditionalists
13 years ago
Sedevacantism: Not “Out Of Context”
14 years ago
Sedevacantist priests who deny Catholic salvation dogma!
14 years ago
Antipope Francis Teaches That Atheists Can Go To Heaven
6 years ago
Ted Kennedy’s Funeral Proves Benedict XVI Is Pro-Abortion
15 years ago
“Cardinal” Wilton Gregory & The Counter Church In Atlanta & DC
1 year ago
Questions: Carroll heresy; stirring in Novus Ordo; non-Catholic friends; the eternity of God the Son
13 years ago
The Heresies Of Benedict XVI
10 years ago
God’s Eternity & Immutability – Denied By Eastern “Orthodox” Speakers
4 years ago
Pro-Abortion Francis Receives Pelosi After Roe v. Wade Overturned
2 years ago
Antipope Francis Gave “Communion” To Pro-Aborts
11 years ago
Catholic vs. “Orthodox” On The Transfiguration Light (Leo, Maximus)
3 years ago
Martin Luther, the Devil and Denominations
15 years ago
Conversation with SSPX supporter – Playlist
16 years ago